JavaScript: The World's Most Misunderstood Programming Language

发布于 2017/03/03 10:58
字数 1045
阅读 10
收藏 0

JavaScript, aka Mocha, aka LiveScript, aka JScript, aka ECMAScript, is one of the world's most popular programming languages. Virtually every personal computer in the world has at least one JavaScript interpreter installed on it and in active use. JavaScript's popularity is due entirely to its role as the scripting language of the WWW.

Despite its popularity, few know that JavaScript is a very nice dynamic object-oriented general-purpose programming language. How can this be a secret? Why is this language so misunderstood?

The Name

The Java- prefix suggests that JavaScript is somehow related to Java, that it is a subset or less capable version of Java. It seems that the name was intentionally selected to create confusion, and from confusion comes misunderstanding. JavaScript is not interpreted Java. Java is interpreted Java. JavaScript is a different language.

JavaScript has a syntactic similarity to Java, much as Java has to C. But it is no more a subset of Java than Java is a subset of C. It is better than Java in the applications that Java (fka Oak) was originally intended for.

JavaScript was not developed at Sun Microsystems, the home of Java. JavaScript was developed at Netscape. It was originally called LiveScript, but that name wasn't confusing enough.

The -Script suffix suggests that it is not a real programming language, that a scripting language is less than a programming language. But it is really a matter of specialization. Compared to C, JavaScript trades performance for expressive power and dynamism.

Lisp in C's Clothing

JavaScript's C-like syntax, including curly braces and the clunky for statement, makes it appear to be an ordinary procedural language. This is misleading because JavaScript has more in common with functional languages like Lisp or Scheme than with C or Java. It has arrays instead of lists and objects instead of property lists. Functions are first class. It has closures. You get lambdas without having to balance all those parens.


JavaScript was designed to run in Netscape Navigator. Its success there led to it becoming standard equipment in virtually all web browsers. This has resulted in typecasting. JavaScript is the George Reeves of programming languages. JavaScript is well suited to a large class of 

non-Web-related applications

Moving Target

The first versions of JavaScript were quite weak. They lacked exception handling, inner functions, and inheritance. In its present form, it is now a complete object-oriented programming language. But many opinions of the language are based on its immature forms.

The ECMA committee that has stewardship over the language is developing extensions which, while well intentioned, will aggravate one of the language's biggest problems: There are already too many versions. This creates confusion.

Design Errors

No programming language is perfect. JavaScript has its share of design errors, such as the overloading of + to mean both addition and concatenation with type coercion, and the error-prone with statement should be avoided. The reserved word policies are much too strict. Semicolon insertion was a huge mistake, as was the notation for literal regular expressions. These mistakes have led to programming errors, and called the design of the language as a whole into question. Fortunately, many of these problems can be mitigated with a good lintprogram.

The design of the language on the whole is quite sound. Surprisingly, the ECMAScript committee does not appear to be interested in correcting these problems. Perhaps they are more interested in making new ones.

Lousy Implementations

Some of the earlier implementations of JavaScript were quite buggy. This reflected badly on the language. Compounding that, those implementations were embedded in horribly buggy web browsers.

Bad Books

Nearly all of the books about JavaScript are quite awful. They contain errors, poor examples, and promote bad practices. Important features of the language are often explained poorly, or left out entirely. I have reviewed dozens of JavaScript books, and I can only recommend oneJavaScript: The Definitive Guide (5th Edition) by David Flanagan. (Attention authors: If you have written a good one, please send me a review copy.)

Substandard Standard

The official specification for the language is published by ECMA. The specification is of extremely poor quality. It is difficult to read and 

very difficult to understand. This has been a contributor to the Bad Book problem because authors have been unable to use the standard document to improve their own understanding of the language. ECMA and the TC39 committee should be deeply embarrassed.


Most of the people writing in JavaScript are not programmers. They lack the training and discipline to write good programs. JavaScript has so much expressive power that they are able to do useful things in it, anyway. This has given JavaScript a reputation of being strictly for the amateurs, that it is not suitable for professional programming. This is simply not the case.


Is JavaScript object-oriented? It has objects which can contain data and methods that act upon that data. Objects can contain other objects. It does not have classes, but it does have constructors which do what classes do, including acting as containers for class variables and methods. It does not have class-oriented inheritance, but it does have prototype-oriented inheritance.

The two main ways of building up object systems are by inheritance (is-a) and by aggregation (has-a). JavaScript does both, but its dynamic nature allows it to excel at aggregation.

Some argue that JavaScript is not truly object oriented because it does not provide information hiding. That is, objects cannot have private variables and private methods: All members are public.

But it turns out that JavaScript objects can have private variables and private methods. (Click here now to find out how.) Of course, few understand this because JavaScript is the world's most misunderstood programming language.

Some argue that JavaScript is not truly object oriented because it does not provide inheritance. But it turns out that JavaScript supports not only classical inheritance, but other code reuse patterns as well.

Copyright 2001 Douglas Crockford. All Rights Reserved Wrrrldwide.




粉丝 13
博文 2
码字总数 0
作品 0
私信 提问
Private Members in JavaScript

JavaScript is the world's most misunderstood programming language. Some believe that it lacks the property of information hiding because objects cannot have private instance var......

(转)Model-View-Controller (MVC) with JavaScript

原文:http://www.alexatnet.com/content/model-view-controller-mvc-javascript The article describes an implementation of Model-View-Controller software design pattern in JavaScrip......

Go language at all time high and in the top 10

July Headline: Go language at all time high and in the top 10 The Go programming language continues to rise. This month it is at an all time high and enters the top 10. This is ......


What is "this"? HEADS UP! This article was written for an older version of node. More up-to-date information may be available elsewhere. Most people that learn JavaScript are co......

Angular model objects with JavaScript classes

Angular model objects with JavaScript classes The missing piece in AngularJS Unlike Backbone and Ember, AngularJS does not provide a standardized way to define model objects. Th......





zk中选举Leader时的网络IO QuorumCnxManager解析

每台服务启动过程中,会启动一个QuorumCnxManager,负责各台服务器之间底层Leader选举过程中的网络通信 当集群中有服务器服务中断时,zk会重新选举leader 内部类 Message定义消息结构 包含了...

使用mdBook 替代 gitbook。

为什么要替代gitbook gitbook 有个模板问题:如果md文件中有连续的大括号(比如:&{{父亲 40}}),gitbook会把{{ 父亲 40 }}中的父亲 40当做一个模板变量。如果这个变量不存在,会报错 Temp...


TL-A7HSAD是一款由广州创龙基于Xilinx Artix-7系列FPGA自主研发的高速数据采集卡,可配套广州创龙TMS320C6655、TMS320C6657、TMS320C6678开发板使用。该采集卡包含1个双通道250MSPS*12Bit的高...


进行项目启动的过程中,之前都正常,这次启动突然就失败了: 查看日志说的是版本过低,后来查看官方网站版本,替换了最新版本: 选择了最新版本的1.2.60,1.2.62尝试后都不行,后来查看网上搜...

McDonald’s is using Alexa and Google to accepting job applications

McDonald’s today announced a new initiative the fast food chain is calling the “Apply Thru,” in which owners of Amazon Alexa or Google Assistant devices can begin job applic......